Marathon | 3 BRs

Amazing Villa

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon was an AMAZING house. It had everything one would need for vacation and beyond! The bedrooms were spacious and beds extremely comfortable. The kitchen was immaculate and had every dish/bowl/ etc one would need! The AC throughout the house was a huge plus…even when the power was lost the generator would kick on and you never noticed any difference. The views are the absolute best…I’ve been staying on STJ for the last 10 years and this was BY FAR the most amazing view and best house. I just can’t recommend this house enough. We will definitely return!

Betsy is AWESOME! She is so sweet and helpful and really goes above and beyond with her communication. I love working with Betsy and know she will always find what we want and help us every step along the way! Betsy makes the process so easy and painless and it’s just a pure joy to work with…we are and will always work with her in the future.

Posted by Dana W

Fabulous!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Everything about Marathon Villa was just perfect!
The layout of the villa, views, pool, outdoor space, appointments & amenities were wonderful & perfect for our family vacation.
We had a fabulous time at Marathon & if it wasn’t for the fabulous beaches & snorkeling on St. John’s, we wouldn’t have left the villa.
We would start our day in the pool, have breakfast on the patio, go to a beach & come back to the pool in the afternoon , have dinner & watch the beautiful sunsets, lights on St. Thomas & amazing stars at night from the patio.
Highly recommend Marathon, and we give it 5 stars.  It was perfect for us & our family.
It was magical & a great time was had by all!

Betsy was wonderful to work with. She was quick with responding to any questions or suggestions.
She set us up with the right people for transfers to & from the airport, ferry transfers, rental cars & suggestions. Everything went very smoothly.
We had a greeter, Becky, meet us at the ferry & take us to the villa, which was very beneficial.
The winding, narrow steep roads in St. John’s & driving on the left was a bit harrowing for driver & passenger, but we all managed.

Posted by Diane G

Fabulous!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Everything about Marathon Villa was just Perfect!
The layout of the villa, views, pool, outdoor space, appointments & amenities were wonderful & perfect for our family vacation.
We had a fabulous time at Marathon & if it wasn’t for the fabulous beaches & snorkeling on St. John’s, we wouldn’t have left the villa.
We would start our day in the pool, have breakfast on the patio, go to a beach & come back to the pool in the afternoon , have dinner & watch the beautiful sunsets , lights on St. Thomas & amazing stars at night from the patio.
Highly recommend we give it 5 stars, it was Perfect for us & our family.
It was Magical & a Great time was had by all!????

Betsy was wonderful to work with. Was quick with responding to any questions or suggestions.
She set us up with the right people for transfers to & from the airport. Ferry transfers, rental cars & suggestions. Everything went very smoothly.
We had a greeter Beky meet us at the ferry & take us to the Villa, which was very beneficial.
The winding, narrow steep roads in St. John’s & driving on the left was a bit harrowing for driver & passenger, but we all managed.

Posted by Diane G

Fabulous!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Everything about Marathon Villa was just Perfect!
The layout of the villa, views, pool, outdoor space, appointments & amenities were wonderful & perfect for our family vacation.
We had a fabulous time at Marathon & if it wasn’t for the fabulous beaches & snorkeling on St. John’s, we wouldn’t have left the villa.
We would start our day in the pool, have breakfast on the patio, go to a beach & come back to the pool in the afternoon , have dinner & watch the beautiful sunsets , lights on St. Thomas & amazing stars at night from the patio.
Highly recommend we give it 5 stars, it was Perfect for us & our family.
It was Magical & a Great time was had by all!

Betsy was wonderful to work with. Was quick with responding to any questions or suggestions.
She set us up with the right people for transfers to & from the airport. Ferry transfers, rental cars & suggestions. Everything went very smoothly.
We had a greeter Beky meet us at the ferry & take us to the Villa, which was very beneficial.
The winding, narrow steep roads in St. John’s & driving on the left was a bit harrowing for driver & passenger, but we all managed.

Posted by Diane G

Paradise

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon villa is beautiful. Clean, comfortable, and a stunning outdoor space.

They were great!

Posted by Deborah D

Marathon Bliss

Marathon, St. John villa review

We just returned from staying at the Marathon Villa in December with 3 couples and this villa was absolutely beautiful along with the sunsets each evening. While the drive to the villa was an adventure at first, we learned how to use central island road to quickly get to other side of the island like Coral & Maho Bay that was great and getting into town was only 5-6 minutes tops.

While we experienced an AC situation in bedroom #3, the owner and WhereToStay really stepped up and addressed it with us that speaks to how they both love this property and want everyone to have only a first class rental experience.

I would definitely stay here again without hesitation.

Excellent.

Special thanks to Betsy for working with owner to get us credit for things we experienced with AC, outside audio and lack of working fireplace for ambiance.

Appreciate the owner stepping up and showing how they care for their property and willingness to provide this credit knowing they want to offer the finest overall experience too!

Posted by Eric N

Beautiful view!!!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon is in a great location with gated access and has one of the best views on the island.

Betsy and the Wheretostay team are the best!!!

Posted by Jeff P

Beautiful view!!!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon is in a great location with gated access and has one of the best views on the island.

Betsy and the Wheretostay team are the best!!!

Posted by Jeff P

Fabulous Stay - Marathon Villa on STJ!

Marathon, St. John villa review

My wife and I traveled with our two nieces (28,24) to St. John for the week in early June. We researched several villas and kept coming back to Marathon Villa because of the beautiful photos. When we arrived, the villa exceeded our expectations. The view from the outdoor patio/pool area is amazing. You can see clear over Great Cruz Bay and see several neighboring islands off in the distance.

The rooms were spacious and clean. The girls loved having their own rooms and balconies that overlooked the pool and enjoyed the same gorgeous views off into the distance.

We used the kitchen several days for breakfast. It is well equipped and allowed us to spend more quality time together as we planned out our journey each day. It was great to have the sound system in the afternoons as we cooled off with a dip in the pool before getting ready for dinner each night.

The location is well suited for exploring the island. 10-15 mins to Cruz Bay and easy access to Centerline to hop up to Windmill Bar for a cocktail or to head on over to Coral Bay for our favorite burger.

Overall this is an excellent villa. We’ve stayed in many different places on STJ and anticipate returning to Marathon Villa when we plan our next trip,

Betsy and the team at WhereToStay were great to work with throughout the entire process. Booking was easy, and communication was great as we took care of final details before our arrival - provisioning the villa, spa recommendations, etc.

Once on island, Jovanna greeted us at the car rental agency and guided us to the villa without any issues and showed us how to work everything once onsite.

Overall, it was a great experience and we will definitely reach out to Betsy again in the future!

Posted by Steve T

Fantastic Villa made for an unbelievable Vacation

Marathon, St. John villa review

We stayed at the stunning Marathon Villa. Marathon provided a stunning view from almost every spot on the property and provided all you would possibly need to make your vacation/stay an outstanding experience. We will definitely be back!!!!!

WhereToStay staff were all very helpful and responsive. A special shoutout to Jalissa for helping us get to the Villa - it was greatly appreciated. Shawna was great to work with. She was very good at keeping us updated on all that needed to be done for our upcoming trip to expedite the process.

Posted by David M

Amazing home - amazing view!!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon has everything you need for a relaxing vacation. The home is well appointed - very clean and well maintained. The kitchen is a full functioning kitchen for anyone who likes to cook and has everything you need. The views are beautiful from every room in the house.
Each bedroom is like a master suite with privacy, comfy bedding and private bathrooms with double sinks! The outdoor living space is spectacular and had us spending much of our time outside enjoying the stunning views. The grounds around the home have beautiful exotic flowers and plants along with local wildlife. A tropical paradise!
All the staff we met from the greeter to the landscapers were friendly and welcoming. When we had questions the staff was just a phone call away. This was a wonderful getaway and we are already planning our next trip!

Working with WhereToStay was Excellent! I had so many questions and everyone was so responsive. They even had a checklist of things to guide you through all of your to-dos before your trip along with tips and recommendations.

Posted by Erin J

Can't wait to come back!

Marathon, St. John villa review

We spent a week at Marathon and had a great time. Shawna and her team were so organized and responsive. The house was literally spotless. The pool was clean and well cared for. Everything we wanted or needed, the house provided. It was just my wife and I at the house but it would be perfect for a family as well. Can’t wait to go back!

Couldn’t thank you, Shawna, enough. All of your recommendations (especially Landlubber’s Logistics) were excellent. We had a great time and will definitely use you and WhereToStay again in the future. Thank you so much!

Posted by James A

Just perfect!!!

Marathon, St. John villa review

New, clean, and beautiful and that view you just can’t get enough of is just as good at night overlooking St. Thomas. Very spacious inside and out. Our best villa yet but very hard to leave.

Booking with WhereToStay was easy as can be. Shawna was always there to answer the phone and our questions. Our greeter, Winnie, was equally as nice and friendly.

Posted by Carl L

Beautiful Home

Marathon, St. John villa review

I have been traveling to St John for 25 years and just discovered my favorite home to rent. Marathon is better than it looks in photos. It is meticulously maintained and has all of the amenities needed for a perfect vacation. The layout is perfect with the pool on the main level as the kitchen and dining area. It was also nice with young children because the two bedrooms upstairs were close enough that everyone slept great knowing we were not too far apart.
We will definitely be back!

Posted by Rebecca G

Wonderful Villa

Marathon, St. John villa review

We have stayed in numerous villas in virtually every location on St John over the years, but Marathon is by far the best and will become our new home away from home in the Caribbean. The views, the privacy, the outdoor entertainment area, the amenities - all excellent. It is the first place we have stayed where it is a tough decision to leave or stay at the villa all day. Would highly recommend this villa to anyone visiting the island or considering a visit.

Shawna was excellent throughout the process and keeping us informed on COVID policy changes prior to arrival. Her recommendations for villa provisioning - Landlubber - made our arrival exquisite and truly relaxing.

Posted by Buck C

Perfect Home, Great Location!

Marathon, St. John villa review

My husband and I recently worked with Shawna at WheretoStay and rented Marathon Villa for the week of 02/18/25/22. We had read online reviews of Marathon as well as did our due diligence prior to renting Marathon Villa. We were absolutely elated, from the moment we entered the villa. This villa is immaculate, only four years old and the layout of the home and the location, high above Great Cruz Bay, in a gated community, with its convenient location, is terrific! The views are beautiful and the sunsets are gorgeous!! Marathon has great outdoor and indoor space as well as the landscaping is the most outstanding you’ll find on St. John. (We have been renting on St. John for 15 years). Marathon Villa is our favorite villa by FAR, and we have stayed in some beautiful villas, but Marathon supersedes any other villa. This is our new “go to” villa on St. John. We will be returning in the future!

Shawna was the consummate professional. She provides excellent communication and was an absolute pleasure to work with not only securing Marathon Villa rental but she went out of her way to help us the day we were checking out of our previous villa (we were fortunate to have rented a different villa, the prior week in Rendezvous Bay. NOTE: We ended up preferring Marathon Villa as it exceeded our expectations!) and moving, late afternoon, to Marathon Villa. We did not have a rental car the day of our move, therefore, we had nowhere to store our luggage until we could get into Marathon Villa. We knew this was an unusual request, but Shawna helped us tremendously by allowing us to store our luggage for several hours so we didn’t have to lug it around the island the day of our transfer. This was going above and beyond customer service!!!! Thanks again, Shawna!! The service you provided was flawless!!

Posted by Ann H

Amazing property with spectacular view

Marathon, St. John villa review

The villa exceeded all of our expectations. The view is incredible, and the villa itself was ‘top notch’ with everything you could want or need. The layout was perfect for 3 adult couples allowing enough privacy for everyone. Perfect outdoor entertaining space. We appreciated the use of beach chairs and coolers. We truly had a vacation full of memories and can’t wait to return!

Excellent she answered all of my questions quickly and everything went smoothly.

Posted by Lisa H

Beautiful!!!

Marathon, St. John villa review

Absolutely beautiful Villa!!! The Villa was exactly as presented. Stunning views!!!

Betsy is amazing!!! She was extremely thorough and very responsive throughout the process. Betsy is a true professional! We will definitely connect with her again!

Posted by Angie H

Absolutely stunning

Marathon, St. John villa review

We stayed at villa with our family, party of 5. It was amazing. We had plenty of room and privacy. The views were breathtaking. The villa was set up perfectly. The outdoor area was just stunning. Pool was absolutely amazing. We spent most of our time in the outdoor area. The bedrooms had privacy and were very comfortable. The kitchen was amazing, more then enough room as we used the kitchen often. The family room was also stunning and very comfortable. Views were amazing no matter where you were in villa. We didn’t want to even leave villa, as you felt so comfortable.
We felt like royalty with our stay at Marathon. Thank you for letting us stay at the most amazing house on the Island.
We will definitely be back.

Working with Shawna at wheretostay was amazing. We were supposed to leave in 2019, but because of covid we had to cancel and reschedule. Shawna was understanding and made us feel comfortable about everything. Her expertise was so helpful. From the moment we started to look at staying in St. John and finding places to stay, her advice was great, she was always eager to answer any questions we had.

Wheretostay was amazing. There concierge service was great. Sharon helped out with everything. From transportation from airport, rental car advice to excursions and much more..they had everything covered. We even had a greeter (Nakira who was also so helpful) meet us upon arrival at island. We can’t say enough about how wheretostay handled everything on our vacation. We definitely will be using them for every vacation.

Posted by Brandon C

Absolutely a Wonderful home

Marathon, St. John villa review

We have stayed at many villas on island but this one I would definitely return to (which I never say). It is spacious, comfortable furniture and bedding, and outstanding outdoor entertainment area, top notch finishings everywhere and an excellent view. I just can’t enough about this home. We loved it and will return!

Shawna was wonderful to deal with and set me at ease with the pandemic and all. Catered Too (on island management) are doing a fine job. The grounds are well maintained, home was clean and our greeter Nakira was very pleasant.

Posted by Tonia C

Amazing

Marathon, St. John villa review

Incredible views and high quality describe this villa. It is well maintained and very comfortable. The Bluetooth capable stereo provides for relaxing music while enjoying the pool and the sunshine.

Andrew was excellent. We added a day to our original booking and he was very helpful in making this happen on short notice. Excellent communication.

Posted by Gary G

Paradise Found

Marathon, St. John villa review

Marathon was every bit as good as the pictures. As soon as you walk through the front door, which leads to the outdoor area, you’re greeted by endless views of blue water and sailboats in the distance. On a clear day, we could actually see all the way to Puerto Rico.

The house was stocked with everything we could possibly want or need. Beds were comfortable and because the house is with concrete walls, privacy was not an issue. The main house is beautiful and takes advantage of all the views from the living room. The grounds around the house were expertly landscaped and we spent a few hours looking at all the flowers and shrubs. We even discovered an orchid growing out of the side of a palm tree. Mind blown!

St John was as beautiful as we hoped and we visited just about every beach on the island, as well as several others on neighboring islands. The roads in St John are the best of any island we’ve visited which makes driving not as much of a “white knuckle” adventure as it does on islands in BVI. Restaurants are top notch but can be tough to get into without reservations. So, plan ahead.

Last, but not least. The great people at WhereToStay were first class during the entire booking process, planning and were standing by if we needed something while on the island. Special shout out to Abby, our host that met us at the dock. She was informative as she was entertaining.

We will definitely to using WhereToStay again in the future!!

Betsy, Sharon and every person I spoke with during the booking process, the week leading up to the trip and during our stay were all Fantastic.

Posted by Todd B

Greta stay

Marathon, St. John villa review

It was definitely the best villa I stayed and a great location . I recommend it for any family with small kids

Posted by Tarkan B

Marathon Villa

Marathon, St. John villa review

We had an amazing stay at Marathon Villa in January 2021. The villa is beautifully built and impeccably maintained with high end Thermador appliances, Caribbean style furnishings, extremely comfortable beds and the best view on island. Centrally located, we were 10 minutes from Cruz Bay, 20 minutes from the north beaches and everything we needed in between. Our stay was enhanced by the excellent service provided to us by Shawna Dunaway with Where To Stay, in fact, we were hesitant to stay in a villa that was not along the water, but she recommended this villa and assured us we would not regret it. She was right! Our stay was 17 days and we watched the sunset every night, from the comfort of our outdoor living area…I’ve been frequenting St John 2-3x per year since 1992 and this, by far, is the best sunset view on island. We have already booked our return trip for 2022 and have locked in the villa for 22 days!

I’ve been looking for a travel partner like Shawna for quite some time. Shawna is very responsive, knowledgeable and a joy to work with! She will be my go-to source for all my island stays from now on. 5 Stars & 2 thumbs up!

Posted by Mary P

Great

Marathon, St. John villa review

The same as last year. Marathon was wonderful - great views of St. Thomas, well equipped, and comfortable furniture. We enjoyed eating out by pool and actually only went out twice. We will come back to Marathon again.

WhereToStay is always great.

Posted by Bob D

Marathon Villa

Marathon, St. John villa review

It is hard to say anything negative about this villa. It is new, clean, and modern. We felt very much at home, and you won’t find a better place on the island to enjoy the sunsets. We like it so much that we are booking Marathon again next year!

Shawna Dunaway is wonderful. She is highly professional, and she adds a lovely, personal touch. I have recommended her to my friends, and I will always reach to her for ideas on where to stay in the Caribbean. She extended herself above and beyond when we were unable to stay at the villa during our expected time. Shawna is a love, and she was very helpful, compassionate, and understanding.

Posted by Dana R

Marathon was absolutely the best villa have rented in over 20 years of renting.

Marathon, St. John villa review

Great views, great layout, wonderfully furnished, nicely equipped kitchen. Because it was so well done and a great view of St. Thomas, we only ate out 3 nights.

Working with Shawna couldn’t have been better.

Posted by Bob D

Fantastic Week in Paradise

Marathon, St. John villa review

We had a group of three couples visit Love City during Carnival and, besides myself, no one else had been to St. John. Needless to say, every one of us absolutely relished in the beauty of the island and the grace of the people. What made it even more special was our stay at Marathon. It was perfect for three couples, as all three bedrooms provided complete privacy, ensuite bathrooms, and spectacular views of Great Cruz Bay, St. Thomas, & neighboring islands. All three bedrooms, which are very nicely appointed, are separate from the well-organized indoor living space and kitchen. The outdoor space and associated views are breathtaking. I’m not overstating this when I say that my wife gasped when we walked through the doors. It is many times better than what is shown in the pictures. Marathon is also in a great area to explore the entire island. We took our daily drive “down and up the hill,” to explore - approximately 10 minutes to town, 20 to the north side beaches, and 30 to Coral Bay. I could go on… if you are looking for a St. John home base that is a well-appointed, fantastic space with easy access, incredible views, with an infinity pool, Marathon should be your choice! It will be ours again, God willing. Cheers!

My experience in working with WhereToStay and Shawna was nothing but fantastic. She is extremely organized, well-communicated, and provided a ton of assistance and great suggestions. I have already recommended her to a few friends and will be reaching out to her when we return - hopefully soon!

Posted by Chris S

Great house and location

Marathon, St. John villa review

Beautiful house, great views, very nice and safe area. Easy drive to town and beaches and Windmill Bar less than 10 minutes away. I didn’t realize when I booked the house several months ago that it had a generator. When I got some emails a couple weeks before our trip about all the power outages on St John the last several weeks, that’s when I discovered our house had one. And our first night the power went out and the generator kicked in and we were all good. The next couple days we lost power a few times and it kicked in we were good. Unfortunately about our 5th day and several outages the fuel tank for the generator ran out so we had no power for a few hours. I called and within about 3 hours they had a maintenance guy and a fuel truck there and we were back in business.
The only problem we had was when we arrived we had no hot water in the kitchen and the master bath on the first floor. And one sink in that same bathroom was clogged and wouldn’t drain. I called and they sent someone out and fixed the kitchen hot water and the clogged drain. We never did have hot water in our bathroom. So cold showers were fun and I had to use the guest bathroom sink in the living area to shave. It had very hot water.
So all in all we will most likely go back to Marathon Villa.

Simply put Betsy is GREAT!!!

Posted by Scott D

very nice house

Marathon, St. John villa review

The house was very nice.

Wheretostay.com and Betsy were excellent! Very organized and efficient making our stay much more enjoyable. I plan to trust them with all of our travel arrangements for that area in the future. My highest recommendation.

Posted by Mike P